Who killed Aarushi Talwar and Hemraj? 9 years later, the mystery remains unsolved
“People mostly remember Aarushi Talwar as the victim. Had 'Aarushi baby', as she was fondly called by Hemraj alias Yam Prasad Banjade, been alive, she would have wanted “The two of them had a very cordial relationship. .. Ads 2 Book · Bank Exam App · ET Money Finance App · CouponDunia. Who killed Arushi Talwar and Hemraj? . that A 13 year old child cannot have relationship with any old age person like hemraj. and when he is lying?how to decide? this test is not reliable in this case. The Noida double murder case refers to the murder of year-old Aarushi Talwar and year-old Hemraj Banjade. Soon after Aarushi's murder, domestic help Hemraj Banjade was of key players and a sound test in the Talwar household to reach the.
She picked up Aarushi from school at 1: Nupur's sister-in-law Vandana Talwar wife of Rajesh's brother Dinesh joined them for lunch. Then Nupur and Vandana left, while Aarushi stayed at home. Nupur worked at the Fortis Hospital from 4: She returned to the apartment around 7.
Sharma dropped Rajesh in front of the apartment building and drove away to park the car at the house of Nupur's parents, which was a walking distance away the Talwars did not have a garage. Sharma returned to the Talwar residence around 9: Sharma saw Nupur and Aarushi near the dining table, and Rajesh coming out of his bedroom.
He was the last known outsider to see Aarushi and Hemraj alive. Rajesh originally planned to give it to Aarushi on her birthday 24 Maybut Nupur persuaded Rajesh to give it to Aarushi that day as an early birthday surprise. Aarushi clicked several photographs of herself and her parents, the last one at Subsequently, Aarushi's parents retired to their room, while Aarushi remained in her room.
Who killed Aarushi Talwar and Hemraj? 9 years later, the mystery remains unsolved
Nupur switched on the router and returned to her own room. Around this time, Rajesh answered a call from the US on the landline phone kept in the couple's room.
This indicates that the ringer was not silent. Rajesh then surfed some stock market and dentistry websites, and sent an e-mail. The calls were not answered. This message was not received by Aarushi's phone. According to their post-mortem reports, Aarushi and Hemraj were killed somewhere between The apartment[ edit ] The sq. Rajesh and Nupur slept in the master bedroomwhile Aarushi slept in an adjacent room.
She had been employed six days earlier. She later stated that she tried pushing the outermost gate, but it did not open. Speaking through the mesh of the middle grill door, she told Bharati that this door was locked from outside.
She asked Bharati about the whereabouts of Hemraj. When Bharati said that she had no idea, Nupur remarked that Hemraj must have gone outside to fetch milk and must have locked the door from outside. She asked Bharati to wait outside until Hemraj returned. Nupur asked her to go downstairs so that she could throw the keys to her from the balcony.
When she tried calling him again, the phone appeared to have been switched off. Nupur then threw the keys down to Bharati.
He entered the living room and saw a near-empty Scotch whisky bottle on the dining table, which surprised him. He asked Nupur who had kept the bottle there, and then alarmed, asked her to check Aarushi's room. Aarushi's room had a self-locking door, and it would generally be locked. It could be opened only from inside or from outside with a key. But the couple found it unlocked on that morning.
When they entered the room, they saw Aarushi's dead body lying on her bed. Rajesh started screaming, while Nupur remained silent due to shock, according to her. She found that the middle door was latched, but not locked. She opened the latch and walked in. Nupur asked her to come inside Aarushi's room.
Bharati stood at the entrance of the room, as Nupur walked inside. Aarushi's body lay on her bed; it was covered with a flannel blanket. Nupur pulled the blanket, and Bharati saw that Aarushi's throat was slit. Both the parents blamed Hemraj for Aarushi's murder in front of the maid. Bharati walked out of the apartment to inform the neighbours. She returned to the house and asked the Talwars if they wanted her to do the daily household chores. When they said "No", she moved on to work in other households.
Puneesh Rai Tandon, a neighbour who lived one floor below the Talwars, asked the Jalvayu Vihar security guard Virendra Singh to inform the police. The crime scene had been "completely trampled upon". In his police complaint, Rajesh blamed Hemraj for his daughter's murder. The police suspected that Hemraj entered Aarushi's room in an inebriated state after consuming Scotch whisky, and tried to sexually assault her. When she resisted, he killed her with a kukri a Nepali knife.
Rajesh's brother Dinesh Talwar, his driver Umesh Sharma and his childhood friend Ajay Chadha accompanied the constables. Will you throw the key down? It's jammed, not locked. But the inner grill gate is latched from outside. As she enters, she finds Rajesh and Nupur crying. Nupur hugs her, weeping: Nupur cries out, "See what Hemraj has done. Aarushi's body is taken for a post-mortem around 9 a. Gautam has clicked ample photos and fingerprints that morning, yet 22 of 24 fingerprints are fuzzy; 23 of his photographs do not match the negatives.
He has no photos of blood-stained footprints on the terrace, where Hemraj's body was found, because "of a large crowd". What about the bloodstained whiskey bottle with fingerprints? His images do not "match anyone's. His new claims have made him a prime witness to the charge of destruction of evidence. Gautam, a retired DSP, decides to drop by at his neighbour Talwar's place.
On a policeman's hunch, he starts checking the flat: Why are three bottles of Sula wine, Kingfisher beer and Sprite lying in Hemraj's room? Have there been more people in the flat that night? What about the three glasses? Why is Hemraj's bed dented, as if three people were sitting on it?
Why is there so much urine in Hemraj's bathroom? Excited, he follows the trail of bloodstains on the stairs near the terrace and finds a bloody terrace, a blood-soaked handprint, a cooler filled with blood-red water and a decomposed body lying in a corner, head bludgeoned like Aarushi's, throat similarly slit, and many injury marks on the body.
On the night of the murder, Rajesh is awake till late, he says, as the home Internet router is on till 3 a. He hears a sound from Aarushi's room, finds Hemraj in her bed, and incensed with rage, clubs both to death. Nupur helps him to complete the crime: They slit necks, drag Hemraj?
And one of the biggest problems of the case was the perception of the parents. In the days immediately following the discovery of the murders, the behaviour of Talwars was viewed as unusual by police and by the public. For days, when Nupur maintained a stoic silence, TV channels went: It's also a cultural process. Across the world, societies differ in what they regard as normal grief. Nupur practised in both places.
It helped to have Nupur's parents? Nupur came from a cosmopolitan Maharashtrian family, says her cousin Shree Paradkar, a Canada-based journalist. Nupur spent the first few years of her life in England, when her father, now a decorated war veteran of the Indian Air Force, was posted at the High Commission in London.
After graduation, they had the option of moving to the US. But they decided to stay back. Happy and confident, with dignified smiles. By Junetheir photos in the media show two people, expressionless and unblinking: Rajesh being taken to jail or Talwars going in for lie-detection, psychological, brainmapping or naro-analysis.
But the case goes through a very different spiral as the CBI takes over from May On July 11,Rajesh is released and domestic workers become the prime suspects. His team has inspected the Talwars'f flat using scientific equipment, like polylight, for tracing blood or semen not visible to the naked eye. Dummy sound tests have revealed that nothing can be heard in the Talwars bedroom with the ACs on.
Nupur and Rajesh are wearing the same clothes the night before and morning after. And cleaning up of crime scene has been done with the permission of the Noida police. Two years later, the Supreme Court of India would rule them unconstitutional but it would let investigators use these tests for leads.
Rajesh and Nupur took two lie-detector and one brain-mapping tests. None showed evidence of deception. Nothing could be heard in their bedroom. The CBI found no evidence that Hemraj had been killed in the house. The agency turned its attention to Krishna. He was the only one who had told state police Rajesh was having an extra-marital affair and that Hemraj and Aarushi were somehow involved.
As well, after Nupur tried calling Hemraj on the morning after the murder, tracking technology showed the phone had been in the cluster of flats where the Talwars lived. Krishna lived there, too. The CBI gave Krishna polygraph and brain-mapping tests. Investigators searched his house and took a pillow cover, a blood-stained kukri and trousers.
The pillow cover would later prove to be crucial evidence. Rajesh was still in jail on July 11, when Arun Kumar held a press conference. The CBI had found no evidence either. What he said next was explosive. After being administered truth serum, Krishna had confessed to the crime and had incriminated two other men — Raj Kumar, a servant, and Vijay Mandal a. Shambhua driver in the neighbourhood. The other two joined them.
She was first hit by a hard, blunt object. They tried to sexually abuse her. That led to a scuffle. They went to a terrace, and on the terrace after a lot of struggle, Hemraj was killed. They locked down the terrace, and came down in the room of Aarushi and then slit her neck. But this drug-induced confession was not enough to charge the men. The agency was going to pursue other evidence, Kumar said. Rajesh was released on bail after 50 days in prison. In September, the three men were also released.
The bail order said polygraph, lie-detector and narco-analysis tests showed they were involved in the killings, but police could find no hard evidence. One year later, Kumar was removed from the case. The state government simply said his tenure at the CBI had ended. Within weeksthe fresh look led to a fresh story. First, the suggestion that her virginity had been long lost.
In India, honour killing is a stereotype of the north, including Punjab. Talwar is a Punjabi surname. Dohare retroactively backed this analysis by making another material addition months later. The CBI analysis also changed the murder weapon that delivered the blunt force. The final report was supposed to provide definitive answers.
It suggested both Nupur and Rajesh were involved in the murders, yet it also sought to close the case. Citing a lack of evidence, investigators sought to close the case. Had the Talwars not challenged the report, they would be free. In reviving the theory first floated by Singh — he of the original press conference — the final CBI report would have saved face, and perhaps careers. It consists of officers drawn from state police forces across the country. In seeking to close the case, the CBI appeared to tempt the Talwars to escape the arduous justice system.
Instead, the Talwars argued the case should not be closed and appealed to a court set up exclusively for cases investigated by the CBI. The court was in nearby Ghaziabad, situated amid dirt alleyways, heaps of garbage and decrepit offices with crumbling walls. As Rajesh left the courtroom and walked past a throng of television cameras after a hearing in Januarya man lunged at him and slashed his face with a meat cleaver, slicing an artery and a nerve.
When Rajesh held up his hands, the cleaver tore into them, cutting tendons and breaking one finger. The vigilante, who was overpowered, said he was upset at the slow pace of the case. It ruled there was enough in the report to charge the Talwars with murder.
With the Talwars standing trial, defence lawyers now had access to all the evidence. They came upon a forensics report dated Nov. Here was evidence that directly tied one of the victims to a man the CBI had originally named a suspect. The Talwars rushed this document to the High Court. How did the CBI explain it? There were no documents to back this assertion. That was on March 18, They took it to the Supreme Court. There, the defence argued that the CBI was relying on flawed evidence to prosecute them.
This test extracts DNA from cells of the outermost layer of skin left behind after touching a surface. Dinesh Talwar, 51, is an ophthalmologist of repute, but he may as well be a lawyer. He has read each word in every case document — there are thousands of pages — and has at his fingertips document numbers, dates and details. He has drastically cut his own clinic hours and his income has been halved. But he is driven by a vow made in to his dying father. Others in the family are trying to drive social media support.
The Facebook group Justice for Aarushi Talwar has 4, supporters. The nascent justice4aarushi handle on Twitter has Friends have started an online petition for the Talwars to be given a fair trial.
And yet, the lifelong struggle is for the Talwars alone.
It had been 14 years since I last saw Nupur. When I left India 12 years ago in search of adventure, Nupur was balancing a career with mothering a 5-year-old.
Noida double murder case - Wikipedia
Not in our wildest imaginations did we foresee the circumstances of our next meeting on Sept 16, A murder charge in India usually means a drawn-out battle for bail. Rajesh has been free sincebut after the CBI charged them both with murder, Nupur was arrested. That was last April. I arrived at Dasna Jail armed with two books for Nupur, a notebook, a pen and a few questions.
Rajesh came with bags of snacks and fresh fruit. A friend of theirs — the woman Rajesh was accused of having an affair with — sent a Bible for a group prayer that a Christian jail guard had organized for Nupur. Her bail hearing was to be held at the Supreme Court the next day. The jail was built in for men and women. Its superintendent, Viresh Raj Sharma, tells me it has 4, inmates. Of these, he says, are convicts.
That means more than 90 per cent of them are awaiting bail or trial, some for years. A majority of the women are accused of killing their daughters-in-law for not bringing sufficient dowry, he says. We waited half an hour, swatting mosquitoes. The whirring fans circulated hot air and the smell of sweat and body odour. The walls had peeling plaster and dark red stains from the spit of chewed betel leaves and tobacco.
We were fingerprinted and frisked and led into the meeting room. Two layers of metal grill separate inmates and visitors and we watched as a dozen prisoners streamed in. The last one stopped in front of us. It took me several seconds to reconcile this fragile woman to my memory of Nupur. We raised our hands to touch fingers through the two square inches of metal.
- Was Aarushi Talwar murder verdict a miscarriage of justice?
- Aarushi Talwar murder: Inside story of India’s most controversial trial
- 2008 Noida double murder case
She looked at me, began to smile, faltered and burst into tears. True to form, she quickly recovered. The towering domed building, made of red and white sandstone, spreads its wings on either side to represent the scales of justice. Proceedings are held in English.
Transcripts are available online. For the CBI, senior advocate Siddharth Luthra, a specialist in criminal law, white-collar crime, extradition and technology.