Caliban and ariel relationship questions

The Tempest Examination Questions and Answers

caliban and ariel relationship questions

The Tempest – Ariel, Prospero and Caliban – a very wonky triangle However we also face a number of questions. what he could to reform the naturally evil Caliban and who had a nice avuncular relationship with Ariel. Relationship between Prospero, Caliban and Ariel in The Tempest Shakespeare's play, The Tempest is set on a mysterious island surrounded by the ocean. Excellent exam questions and sample answers on Shakespeare's The Tempest. The Contrast Between Ariel and Caliban in Shakespeare's Tempest · The Relationship Between Miranda and Ferdinand · The Tempest: Stages of Plot.

Their relationship if such it is is a resounding blank. Your suggestion that Caliban and Ariel work together to overthrow Prospero is one oddly neglected by Shakespeare.

Christian Smith I agree with Zsolt that there is more to the story than what I wrote in my comment and will take his suggestion to extend my interpretation in light of Hegel and Marx. In paragraph of Ph.

After much time of being alienated from his labour power the worker loses the possibility of this philosophically-contrived consciousness and succumbs to an emptying of his Geist. It is emptied of its knowledge about its actual situation and of its history. Consequently it is emptied of the consciousness of its revolutionary future.

Marx uses quotes from and allusions to Shylock to describe a Geist with its heart cut out — the reified consciousness. Ariel sinks the ship and distributes the crew on the island. Ariel enchants Ferdinand and the others with his music and then saves the King from regicide.

caliban and ariel relationship questions

He tricks the conspirators and then torments them with the Harpies. Ariel drives the characters all over the island and in the end, it is Ariel who attires Prospero. Lurking under the surface of this play is the possibility that at any point, Ariel could have gone on strike, or, worse, united with Caliban and defeated the humans. Ariel seems to have become alienated from his power. When Ariel has acquired a mind of his own he tells Prospero to be empathic.

To see the suffering of his usurpers-turned-captives and to forgive them. Ariel moves Geist to the state of mutual recognition. It will, of course, take more work to rehabilitate Sebastian and Antonio.

Well, Gonzalo dreamed it up for us. Nevertheless, I think that this dialectic may be developed in another direction as well. This continuation of the story has not always been recognized, although this continuation may well be applicable to The Tempest too, if one intends to stick to reading the text in the light of the Master -Slave dialectic.

Also the work power that is required from Caliban is a complicated issue, as he is not represented as someone who would act as a proper slave.

The revolutionary practice is also frustrating, at least with respect to the outcome of the revolutionary activity, since both Ariel and Caliban obtain what they needed: Arial is rewarded with freedom, Caliban receives his island back.

Thus, in the revolutionary perspective this outcome is rather pessimistic: Why be active, then? Thanks again for the post, and for the comment as well.

caliban and ariel relationship questions

Christian Smith One issue that you raise here is the relationship between the Slave and the Master. Prospero was helped to survive on the island by Caliban, who could have simply eaten him cannibal when he washed ashore. It is this devotion to study that has made him content to raise Miranda in isolation.

caliban and ariel relationship questions

Prospero will have to let go of his magic to return to the world where his knowledge means something more than power. Prospero is a considerate character in that he was wronged by his usurping brother, but his absolute power over the other characters makes him difficult to like.

In our first glimpse of Prospero, he appears puffed up and self-important, and his repeated insistence that Miranda pays attention suggests that his story is boring her. Act I Scene II. So, the Prospero and Ariel relationship is one of master-servant but the servant willingly obeys the master in exchange for later benefits in this case, Ariel obeys Prospero to obtain his freedom.

Relationships Of Prospero And Caliban 📚 The Tempest

The Epilogue is the only scene in the play in which we see Prospero ask others — the audience — for help. It shows him as a mere mortal who, stripped of his magic powers, is as vulnerable as the rest of us. It is incumbent on the audience to exhibit the same sort of mercy as he has just shown, indicating that we too have learnt to be magnanimous.

For some critics, this new Prospero inspires admiration and sympathy. For others, he is now an impotent tyrant who, without any method of self-defence, is in a position to be punished for the wrongs he has done to the others characters during the play.

Prospero treats Caliban as a slave. The general complaint by those who have read the play, including most college professors, use the alleged complaint of rape as a justifiable reason for the poor treatment Caliban receives at the hands of all who come into contact with him.

But this is taking political correctness too far, in my opinion. Before we even meet Caliban, Shakespeare already builds suspense around him: We are already given information on Caliban so that we are prejudiced about him before he enters the story. The first few things we hear about Caliban forms an animalistic view of the man.

Caliban and ariel

His mother Sycorax was from Argier, and his father Setebos seems to have been a Patagonian deity.